| NL Cy Young | Jason Schmidt or Josh Beckett | John Smoltz | Jason Schmidt | Jason Schmidt |
| AL Rookie of the Year | Gabe Gross or Jason Bartlett | Jeremy Reed | Nick Swisher | Russ Adams |
| NL Rookie of the Year | Jose Capellan | Clint Barmes or Jeff Francis | Chris Burke | Clint Barmes |
| AL Free Agent Flop of the Year | Steve Finley | Jaret Wright | Magglio Ordonez | David Wells |
| NL Free Agent Flop of the Year | Vinny Castilla and Christian Guzman | Jose Valentin | Russ Ortiz | Jeromy Burnitz |
| NL Comeback Player | Raul Mondesi and Josh Beckett | Chipper Jones | Ryan Dempster | Ken Griffey, Jr. |
| Best Value Free Agent | Mike Matheny ($10.5m/3) and Raul Mondesi ($1m) | Wade Miller (1 year, $1.5m) | Wade Miller | Wade Miller |
| Team with most steroid suspensions | Yankees | Yankees | Rangers | Reds |
| Biggest decline from '04 to '05 | Rangers | Giants | Rangers | Astros |
| First on DL of K. Griffey, F. Thomas, or N. Garciaparra | Thomas | Thomas | Griffey | Thomas |