| Adam Conn | Matt Phillips | Brian Wilmer | Ed Barnes |
| AL Cy: |
1. J. Santana
2. C. Schilling
3. B. Radke |
1. J. Santana
2. C. Schilling
3. P. Martinez |
1. J. Santana 2. C. Schilling 3. J. Westbrook | 1. J. Santana 2. C. Schilling 3. M. Rivera |
| NL Cy: |
1. Schmidt
2. Clemens
3. Oswalt |
1. Schmidt
2. Clemens
3. Pavano |
1. Clemens 2. Pavano 3. C. Zambrano | 1. Clemens 2. Johnson 3. Schmidt |
| AL MVP: |
1. V. Guerrero
2. M. Ramirez
3. G. Sheffield | 1. G. Sheffield
2. M. Ramirez
3. D. Ortiz |
1. V. Guerrero 2. M. Ramirez 3. G. Sheffield | 1. Guerrero 2. Sheffield 3. Ramirez |
| NL MVP: |
1. A. Beltre
2. B. Bonds
3. A. Pujols/J. Edmonds |
1. B. Bonds
2. A. Pujols
3. A. Beltre |
1. A. Beltre 2. B. Bonds 3. A. Pujols | 1. B. Bonds 2. A. Beltre 3. A. Pujols |
| AL Reliever of the Year: |
1. J. Nathan
2. M. Rivera
3. F. Cordero |
1. M. Rivera
2. J. Nathan
3. F. Cordero |
1. J. Nathan
2. M. Rivera
3. F. Cordero | 1. M. Rivera 2. J. Nathan 3. F. Cordero |
| NL Reliever of the Year: |
1. E. Gagne
2. A. Benitez
3. D. Kolb | 1. E. Gagne
2. A. Benitez
3. J. Isringhausen |
1. E. Gagne 2. J. Isringhausen 3. A. Benitez
| 1. E. Gagne 2. A. Benitez 3. J. Isringhausen |
| AL Rookie of the Year: |
1. Bobby Crosby
2. Shingo Takatsu
3. Daniel Cabrera | 1. Bobby Crosby
2. Shingo Takatsu
3. Daniel Cabrera |
1. Bobby Crosby
2. Shingo Takatsu
3. Daniel Cabrera |
1. Bobby Crosby
2. Shingo Takatsu
3. Daniel Cabrera |
| NL Rookie of the Year: |
1. K. Greene
2. J. Bay
3. A. Otsuka/N. Lowry | 1. K. Greene
2. J. Bay
3. D. Wright |
1. K. Greene 2. M. Holliday 3. J. Bay |
1. K. Greene 2. J. Bay 3. A. Otsuka |
| AL Flop: |
1. A. Rhodes
2. E. Guardado
3. R. Aurilia | 1. Ju. Gonzalez
2. J. Giambi
3. B. Boone |
1. E. Hinske 2. B. Boone 3. E. Loaiza | 1. A. Rhodes 2. Ju. Gonzalez 3. A. Berroa |
| NL Flop: |
1. R. Sexson
2. K. Matsui
3. R. Simon/J.Payton |
1. R. Simon 2. A. Pettitte 3. S. Sosa |
1. H. Nomo 2. M. Cameron 3. S. Sosa | 1. H. Nomo 2. J. Payton 3. H. Choi |
| AL Comeback Player: |
1. J. Leiber
2. P. Konerko
3. J. Dye
|
1. O. Hernandez
2. P. Konerko
3. J. Lieber |
1. B. Inge 2. R. Lopez 3. T. Hafner | 1. J. Dye 2. B. Inge 3. D. Delluci |
| NL Comeback Player: |
1. C. Carpenter
2. E. Milton
3. J. Wright | 1. J.D. Drew 2. C. Carpenter 3. J.
Wright |
1. J. Wilson 2. J. Wright 3. Oliver Perez | 1. C. Carpenter 2. J. Wright 3. T. Hoffman |
| AL Manager of the Year: |
1. Eric Wedge
2. Ron Gardenhire
3. Buck Showalter |
1. Buck Showalter
2. Ken Macha 3. Eric Wedge |
1. Mike Scioscia 2. Terry Francona 3. Ron Gardenhire | 1. Buck Showalter 2. Ron Gardenhire 3. Mike Scioscia |
| NL Manager of the Year: |
1. B. Cox
2. P. Garner
3. T. La Russa | 1. J. Tracy 2. B. Bochy 3. B. Cox
|
1. B. Cox 2. J. Tracy 3. P. Garner | 1. B. Cox 2. J. Tracy 3. F. Alou |
| Best GM of the Year: |
1. W. Jocketty
2. T. Ryan
3. B. Stoneman |
1. W. Jocketty
2. J. Schuerholz
3. B. Stoneman |
1. B. Stoneman 2. J. Schuerholz 3. D. Melvin | 1. W. Jocketty
2. J. Schuerholz
3. B. Stoneman |
| Worst GM of the Year: |
1. Bill Bavasi
2. Joe Garagiola Jr.
3. Jim Duquette | 1. Jim Duquette 2. Joe Garagiola Jr.
3. Bill Bavasi |
1. Allard Baird 2. Bill Bavasi 3. Ken Williams |
1. Bill Bavasi
2. Joe Garagiola Jr. 3. Paul DePodesta |
| Best Milestone achieved this year: | Greg
Maddux becomes perhaps the last 300 game winner | Bonds 700th HR & Ichiro breaking Sisler's record | Ichiro breaking Sisler's record | Ichiro breaking Sisler's record
|
| World Series Prediction: |
St. Louis Cardinals over Boston Red Sox in 6 games |
New York Yankees over St. Louis Cardinals in 7 games |
Boston Red Sox over Houston Astros in 6 games |
Boston Red Sox over Houston Astros in 7 games |
| World Series MVP Prediction: |
Albert Pujols | Alex Rodriguez | Manny Ramirez | Curt Schilling
|
| 2005 Hall of Fame Electees: | Wade Boggs Ryne Sandberg |
Wade Boggs Ryne Sandberg Bruce Sutter | Wade Boggs Ryne Sandberg | Wade Boggs
|